Cloudinary Blog

A story about production systems, Rails, monitoring and off-hour notifications

by Nadav Soferman
Cloudinary's image management service is used by thousands of world-wide websites and mobile apps. For many of our clients, Cloudinary has become a central, mission-critical component used for managing image uploads, transformations and delivery.
 
This is why we've built Cloudinary from the ground up to be a very robust service. We put a lot of emphasis on availability, scalability and support and we take our users' confidence in us extremely seriously.
 
So far, we've been quite satisfied with our ability to keep Cloudinary at an average of > 99.99% uptime.
 
However, on April 4th, the Cloudinary service experienced outages for a few hours. We wanted to explain what happened, our conclusions and the steps we've taken to make sure this won’t happen again.
 

The upgrade

Cloudinary's core service is built with Ruby on Rails. The service is tested thoroughly and upgrades are handled with uttermost care. This is why we've preferred to stay with Rails v3.0 for a long time rather than rock the boat with an upgrade to the latest Rails 3.2.
 
A few weeks ago a security vulnerability was discovered in Rails. As always, we wanted to apply the security fix as soon as possible. However, the Rails team stopped releasing fixes for Rails 3.0. We had to upgrade to v3.2.
 
We've upgraded to Rails 3.2 in our lab and modified our code to support it (Rails upgrades tend to be non backward compatible and break code built with previous versions). We've tested our code extensively and verified that our thousands of unit tests passed correctly. We've successfully finished a thorough manual QA of the system in our staging environment. It all went quite smoothly.
 
We scheduled the upgrade for April 4th. As usual, we deployed the system gradually to all of our production servers. Deployment went smoothly as well. We performed additional sanity testing after the system was deployed and closely monitored the system during the working day.
 
We went to sleep happy and relaxed.
 

The issues

At about 1am at night things started to shake.
 
Apparently, Rails 3.2 changed the defaults of one simple configuration parameter - response caching was turned on by default when certain cache headers are returned.
 
As a result, after long hours of service requests, the local application disk for some of our servers became full due to the cached responses. This caused certain requests that required disk space to fail, depending on the exact request and the size of the response.
 
Annoyingly enough, the automatic monitoring service that regularly verifies our APIs, was performing a request that required very little disk space and continued to operate regularly. This service is configured to send notifications to our engineering team's mobile phones during the night. But since no errors were detected, no notification was sent.
 
Fortunately for us, our co-founder's toddler woke him up early in the morning. He naturally (?) checked his inbox, understood that something was very wrong. He quickly cleared the disk space and modified Rails 3.2 cache settings. The system was fully working again.
 
It's important to note that during these ~5 hours, all existing images and transformed images were delivered successfully to users through our delivery service and tens of thousands of worldwide CDN edges (Akamai + CloudFront). Still, part of the upload API calls did fail during this time and we are very sorry for this.
 

Going forward

Naturally, we've immediately started to improve our outage prevention mechanisms.
 
We've added additional disk space tests to our QA list and added abnormal disk usage monitoring to our urgent notification service. We're also adding a wider set of API requests to our automatic service monitoring.
 
We've integrated with Twilio to enhance our off-hour notifications. Specifically, our engineering team will now receive automatic voice calls to their mobile phones in addition to our previous notification methods.
 
To make sure we keep you in the know during outages, we've pushed up the priority of a public status page. This page will include automatic monitoring details as well as human written notes.
 

Summary & conclusions 

We are happy that Cloudinary had nearly zero availability issues in almost 2 years of operations. On the other hand, no online service is perfect and every service experienced or will experience outages. 
 
We will continue to enhance our service with additional image-related features. On the same time, we'll continue to work hard on having Cloudinary's uptime as close to 100% as possible.
 
Thank you for trusting us with your images!
blog comments powered by Disqus

Recent Blog Posts

Control the zoom level with automatic image cropping

Many websites now offer their users the ability to upload images and profile pictures, making it a challenge for web designers to maintain a certain graphic design and style when subsequently displaying these images. The profile pictures may need to be smartly cropped to focus on the faces, with some sites that prefer close-ups of faces and others that prefer including more background when displaying images of people.

Read more
Introducing cloud based service for video management

They say that a picture is worth a thousand words. For modern websites, a video surely takes the visual impact to a whole new level.

Nowadays, people enjoy the amazing capability of shooting videos with smartphone cameras that easily fit in their back pockets and are accessible nearly everywhere. Modern web applications have an opportunity to dramatically increase their visual impact by showcasing these videos online. Between news reports, user shared video snippets, explainer videos and ad campaigns, we see more and more videos appearing daily in our visited websites.

Read more
Automatic and accurate red eye removal with Cloudinary

Red eye often happens due to the use of flash in low light conditions as the light hits the eye very quickly and into the retina. It then bounces off of the back of the eye and emits a red color due to the blood vessels there. Although more professional modern cameras and flashes generally prevent this from happening, red eye may still occur with simpler, smaller cameras (including smartphones). There are various software solutions for red eye removal available on mobile devices and desktops, some of which require manual processing to get good results.

Read more
How to detect and prevent malware infected user uploads

Social networking sites allow users to upload images or other types of files that are immediately available to other users via news feeds or notifications. In some cases, attackers can directly spread infected files, but more commonly, they leverage the viral effect and the fact that users are simply unaware that their files are infected through sharing and collaborating with others. As a site owner or application developer, it is your responsibility to protect users and prevent these situations from occurring. Fortunately, Cloudinary makes this easier with its Metascan add-on.

Read more