Cloudinary Blog

PNG optimization - saving bandwidth on transparent PNGs with dynamic underlay

by Nadav Soferman
PNG optimization - saving bandwidth on transparent PNGs with dynamic underlay
There are many ways to optimize PNG files, but one optimization which is commonly overlooked involves the PNG's transparent background. If you’ve chosen to use PNGs instead of a more compact format like JPG, mainly for the PNG's support of a transparent background (alpha channel), read on and see how dynamic underlays can reduce your file size by as much as 1:5.
 
Graphic designers of sites and apps sometimes wish to display clipped photos on top of a certain background. A common example is a news site that shows a head shot of the author, or a figure mentioned in the article. Typically, the images are clipped using photo editing software like Photoshop, and then they can then be placed above background colors, patterns and between text paragraphs. 
 
The issue is that the image may be placed in different contexts, and in each context the background could have a different color. The need arises to give the image a transparent background, and this requires a file format that supports transparency (alpha channel). The format typically chosen is PNG, and this can increase file size substantially.
 

How it's usually done - image saved as transparent PNG

For example, the following photo of a person was taken. It was saved using the JPG format as expected.
 
Business man photo
 
Then a graphic designer manually edited and clipped the photo. In order to maintain transparency (alpha channel) of the clipped photo, the image is uploaded using the PNG format that supports transparency, in contrast to the JPG photo format. 
 
Transparent background PNG thumbnail
 
This allows the image to be placed on any background, however, the PNG format is not optimal for photos. The generated thumbnail weighs 59.8KB - almost 500% its weight as a 90%-quality JPG, which is 12.4KB. That might be a huge waste of bandwidth and money. It also harms the browsing experience of users, who need to wait much longer for images to load.
 

Now check this out - PNG optimization with dynamic background color

Here's an idea to dramatically cut the image size - not use PNG at all. The graphic designer can save the file as JPG and apply the desired background color dynamically.
 
One way to do this is by uploading the cropped photo to Cloudinary, and adding the dynamic background on the fly. In case you're new here, Cloudinary is a cloud-based system that can help you store, administrate, manipulate and deliver your website’s images. Image manipulation is performed dynamically using URLs or API calls you can easily generate within your code.
 
The first step is to deliver the image as a JPG with 90% quality. Note that Cloudinary can also crop the clipped photo to 200x250, on-the-fly, based on the automatically detected face. 
 
White background JPG
 
 
We're now down to 12.4KB for the file - almost 1/5 of its weight when it was saved as PNG. But of course the graphic designer still has the same problem - now to place the image over a non-white background, as in the example below. 
 
White background JPG on a red background
 
In Cloudinary, one simple solution is to create a JPG thumbnail on the fly, which already has the background color you need for the thumbnail. While you can do this manually using photo editing software, you definitely don't want to create many different versions for all possible background colors in your site and modify them when your graphic design changes.
 
The following example sets the 'background' transformation parameter (or 'b' for URLs) to an RGB color (#c11e31 red color in this case). The result is the same JPG image, which is dynamically generated with a red background that can now be placed nicely on top of the page's red background. 
 
The generated JPG image weighs just 12.8KB, an optimization compared to the PNG option. The JPG image saves 80% of bandwidth and improves page load time. In addition, you can dynamically modify the color parameter of the manipulation URL to any desired color of your site or app.
 
 
 
Red background JPG
  Green background JPG  Blue background JPG
 
Same image tag and URL generation in PHP:
<?php echo cl_image_tag("business_man_clipped.jpg",
        array( "width" => 200, "height" => 250, "crop" => "fill",
               "gravity" => "face", "background" => "#c11e31" )); ?>
In addition, further filters and effects can be applied on the clipped photo. The example below dynamically increases the strength of the red channel, reduces opacity, reduces color saturation and reduces contrast.

Watermark with red background JPG 
 
 

A harder case - PNG optimization with image-based backgrounds

The examples above are useful for a solid background color. However, modern websites might have gradient backgrounds or image-based backgrounds. Cloudinary can assist in optimizing bandwidth usage and user experience in this case as well.
 
For example, the following background image was uploaded to Cloudinary with the public ID of 'bn_bg_wide'.
 
 
Blue background sample
 
 
This image weighs 18.4KB. Saving it as a transparent background PNG means an extra 59KB, for a total weight as PNG of 78.2KB. Optimizing the PNG using a JPG image with a solid background is not an option at all in this case. Again, you can manually create a JPG image with the clipped photo and the background image underneath, but this will not work when you have plenty of photos and different background images. 
 
You can use Cloudinary's dynamic image overlays and underlays to overcome this issue and optimize the PNG.
 
In the following example, Cloudinary dynamically adds the cropped photo of the person as an overlay, 20 pixels from the top right corner, while scaling down the clipped photo to a height of 220 pixels.
 
 
Transparent background person on a blue image 
 
The resulting image weighs 24.8KB. This PNG optimization saved almost 70% of image size and bandwidth. 
 
Building the same URL, this time in Node.js:
cloudinary.image("bn_bg_wide.jpg",
  { overlay: "business_man_clipped", height: 220, crop: "fill",
    gravity: "north_east", x: 20, y: 20 })
Another option: instead of adding the clipped photo as an overlay, create a 200x250 face detection based thumbnail of the clipped photo and add the blue background image as an underlay image. 
 
 
Blue underlay image
 
 
The generated JPG image image including the underlay, weighs just 13.7KB.
 
Same example using Python (and Django):
cloudinary.CloudinaryImage("business_man_clipped.jpg").image(
  transformation = [
    { "width": 200, "height": 250, "crop": 'fill', "gravity": "face" },
    { "underlay": "bn_bg_wide", "width": 1.0, "height": 1.0,
      "flags": 'relative', "crop": 'crop', "gravity": 'north_east' }] )

 

Using the WebP format - and delivering it only on supported browsers

Another simple option to optimize the PNG is to convert and deliver the clipped image using the WebP format. This modern format is optimized for photos and also supports transparent backgrounds. 
 
The following 200x250 thumbnail was automatically converted by Cloudinary to the WebP format with the high 90% quality. The resulting image weighs just 10.5KB. This means saving 82% of the size and bandwidth of the PNG image, while having an almost identical result.
 

Red background WebP
 
 
The following Ruby on Rails command creates an image tag with the same manipulation and CDN delivery URL:
<%= cl_image_tag("business_man_clipped.webp", :width => 200, :height => 250, 
                 :crop => :fill, :gravity => :face, :quality => 90 %>
The only issue with the WebP format is that most browsers don't support it yet. Google Chrome and Android are the only major platforms that currently supports it. You can use Cloudinary's smart URLs with the 'f_auto' parameter which delivers using the WebP format to supported devices and using the PNG format to other devices.
 
 
You can read more about selective WebP image delivery here: Transparent WebP format CDN delivery based on visitors' browsers
 

Summary

One of our missions at Cloudinary is to optimize the performance of our customers' sites and apps, while improving their user experience and saving them money by reducing unnecessary bandwidth usage. Together with other cloud-based image manipulation capabilities, developers can perform complex image manipulations with optimized size and delivery, without spending precious time on achieving these tasks manually or building the automation themselves.
 
In this blog post we showed a use case in which we easily save about 80% of bandwidth with a simple PNG optimization, while delivering photos using Cloudinary's cloud-based image management. These capabilities are available in our perpetual free plan. We invite you to sign up, try out the dynamic background and overlay features, give us some feedback and share your insights in the comments below. 
 

Recent Blog Posts

Why JPEG is like a photocopier

by Jon Sneyers
Why JPEG is like a photocopier (generation loss)

If you make a copy of a copy of a copy, the quality will deteriorate with every ‘generation’. This problem is called ‘generation loss’. It is not difficult to understand why this happens with actual copier machines. Scanning and printing are not perfect, being based on noisy sensors and physical paper and ink, and the resulting noise will tend to accumulate.

Read more
Apply conditions to dynamically manipulate images.

It's great to have the capability to manipulate images on the fly by using dynamic URLs to customize the images to fit the graphic design of your site or mobile application. However, what if you want to manipulate an image depending on a specific image characteristic (like its width or aspect ratio) or its contents (does it contain a face?). What you need is a way to apply a transformation to an image only if a specific condition is met. Take for example a situation where you have allocated space on your page for a user uploaded image with a width and height of 200 pixels. Furthermore, if the image contains a face you would like to zoom in and focus on the face itself, otherwise you would like to fit the entire image into the available space:

Read more
Moviepilot focus on core business and reduce costs
 
Moviepilot Inc. is a media company that hosts a website and social publishing platform designed to bring together movie and TV fans, and help studios trigger, fuel and amplify positive conversations about entertainment topics. The site invites fans to create content, such as writing articles and producing videos, which are then curated on the site and distributed to more than 30 million fans worldwide. The site boasts more than 20 million unique visitors per month, with 87 percent of visitors accessing the site on mobile devices. The company is headquartered in Venice Beach, Calif., and has an office Berlin, Germany, where it was originally founded.
Read more
Powerful facial detection for image manipulation

Many of the photos displayed on the internet these days are of people. If your website or mobile application displays photos that include people, you will want to make sure that their faces are included in the delivered images when cropping and manipulating them to fit your graphic design and responsive layout. You may even want to further manipulate an image according to the faces present, for example, adding a harlequin mask overlay on all of their eyes, where each mask is adjusted to the correct size and orientation (although not a typical use case, it's a cool example of using advanced facial attribute detection):

Read more